Nestled in East Hampton, interdisciplinary design firm Hart Howerton preserved and enhanced the architecture of a historic 1913 Shingle Style residence, with interior design by Champalimaud Design and landscape design by Oehme van Sweden. The home honors preservation while thoughtfully evolving its form and function to support contemporary coastal living. From the start, the homeowners immediately saw what made the home special, and from the beginning of the design, their primary question was: how do we preserve this beauty while making it a home for today? That spirit guided every decision.
The architectural history of East Hampton is interwoven with the Shingle Style architecture of the late 19th century. Dr. Frederick K. Hollister built four Shingle Style cottages in East Hampton's estate section, all of them architecturally significant. His second cottage is notable for its understatement and because it possesses everything that is unique to the Shingle Style. Designed by John Custis Lawrence, the most notable feature is the full width of the house at 110 feet.From inception, Hart Howerton’s vision saw the design as an opportunity to preserve and restore the original home’s architecture while introducing an addition that remained visually and materially consistent with its historical context.
The original footprint of the home was maintained in its entirety with minimal intervention. Every original element of the home was restored when possible, and when materials could no longer be salvaged, Hart Howerton sourced historically accurate materials, including Eastern White cedar shingles, salvaged brick, and cypress windows and doors adorned with restoration glass. Inside the home, decades of paint were carefully stripped from the original cypress paneling, revealing the home’s original architectural expression through the natural warmth and texture of the wood.
Materials used throughout the project were chosen for their historic character and their ability to weather gracefully over time. The home’s muted palette of weathered shingles and soft putty-gray trim allows it to recede into its surroundings. Interior finishes echo this tone, with traditional oak strip flooring, classic brass fixtures, and the restoration of all original cypress paneling found throughout the main entertainment spaces in the home.
This project is rooted in both preservation and sustainability. A geothermal system was implemented, significantly reducing energy consumption and eliminating the need for visible outdoor equipment. The walls were insulated, and new, thermally efficient windows were installed. Choosing to restore the home rather than tear down and start anew reinforced the project’s commitment to sustainability.
To create minimal impact on the land, the landscape was limited to simple brick walks and a modest pool surrounded by lawn and native vegetation. Existing garden rooms and their connection to the surrounding landscape were preserved, and the addition was designed to flow naturally into the outdoor spaces.
The addition of a new stair transformed the entry foyer while remaining consistent with the home’s original detailing. Upstairs, the original low-ceilinged guest rooms were reframed to create more generous, light-filled spaces, often opening the attics above to create cathedral ceilings. When it was determined the home must be temporarily lifted to repair its original brick foundation, a full basement was newly excavated and designed, and now features tall ceilings, ample daylight, and a bunk room for visiting guests.
The project was awarded the East Hampton Village Preservation Society’s annual award for preservation. This recognition affirms the intent of the project to restore while expanding the home with care and contributing meaningfully to the architectural continuity of the East Hampton community. While many homes in the area have been lost to time or redevelopment, the residence stands as an investment in history and design.
For Hart Howerton, the residence represents a design philosophy rooted in place and craft. It is a restoration and expansion in equal measure, carefully considered from massing to materials to mechanical systems. The house now stands as a renewed vision, while maintaining the spirit of its original architecture through exemplary restoration and thoughtful design.
Team:
Architecture: Hart Howerton
Interiors: Champalimaud Design
Landscape: Oehme Van Sweden Landscape Architecture
Photographer: Trevor Tondro